A gas company has filed a half-dozen lawsuits against 16 agricultural landowners who have refused access to their property.

(Photo: Courtesy of U.S. Sugar)
In the century since Donia Roberts’ grandparents came to western Palm Beach County from Iowa to farm vegetables and later sugarcane, her family has battled freezes, droughts, floods, hurricanes, pests and diseases.
Now, Roberts and 15 other farmers and agricultural landowners in the Glades are fighting a new challenge to their livelihood: a 38-mile natural gas pipeline across their properties.
Florida Gas Transmission Co., which wants to build the pipeline from Martin County to South Bay in southwestern Palm Beach County, has filed a half-dozen lawsuits in Palm Beach, Martin and Hendry counties against the 16 owners after they all refused the company’s request to enter their properties to begin surveys and tests as part of the permitting process.
The defendants include Clewiston-based U.S. Sugar and property owners who lease farmland to U.S. Sugar, the nation’s largest sugarcane producer. It received — and rejected — a request from FGT to drill “100-foot boreholes” to collect samples, U.S. Sugar spokesperson Ryan Duffy said.
Such holes could penetrate the aquifer, he said. The pipeline is slated to cross about 15 miles of U.S. Sugar property, he said.
“A project of this scale could permanently alter our land, affect its value and disrupt the farming operations our region depends on,” Duffy said. “Here in the Glades, when something affects our neighbors, we sit down with them and work through it together.
“The pipeline company chose to start with a demand. We oppose that demand and will defend our property rights.”
FGT said in an October court filing that it has a “clear legal right” to enter the properties, and that the pipeline is needed to improve energy reliability and meet South Florida’s growing demand for natural gas.
Natural gas fuels about three-quarters of the state’s electricity, and demand is likely to continue rising thanks to population growth, increased industrial growth and the potential for data centers.

In an October earnings call, NextEra Energy, the parent company of Florida Power & Light Co., said it would announce by year-end a plan to build a multibillion-dollar data center in Florida.
A controversial data center known as Project Tango has been approved in Palm Beach County on the eastern edge of the cane fields as well.
But Roberts, who owns 200 acres with her three sisters and mother, Frances Adams, calls FGT’s effort a “private taking” of her land that would spell the end of the family farm.
“It is not a public taking. It would put me out of business. I can’t afford to put up a legal fight to protect my private property rights,” said Roberts, a Wellington resident and an attorney with a practice in Belle Glade. “It’s taking our land out of production. Remember, we do feed the world.”
Does gas company have right to access their land?
The 24-inch underground pipeline would go through FPL’s Martin Power Plant to its South Bay Substation. Then it would connect with another pipeline in the works, the Florida Energy Pathway, a 97-mile project from South Bay to Miami.
At the heart of the dispute are two Florida statutes. One grants qualifying natural gas companies eminent domain, examination, survey and entry powers. The other empowers surveyors to conduct surveys and mapping on behalf of the gas company when necessary.
However, the landowners contend that they have a constitutional right to exclude others, including the gas company, from their land. If the court disagrees, the landowners are seeking full compensation.
The proposal comes at a difficult time for growers. A January freeze socked Palm Beach County farmers with $1.15 billion in sugarcane losses, as well as $255.4 million in sweet corn losses, Florida Agriculture Commissioner Wilton Simpson said.
Glades farmers also lost 80% of their crops in floods this month, said Paul Allen, president of R.C.Hatton Farms in Pahokee. Allen declined to comment on the planned pipeline.
And now, South Florida farmers are busy planting and harvesting, said Roberts, who grew up on her family’s farm in Canal Point. Visits from gas company workers or contractors would disrupt farming operations and aren’t welcome, she said.
“It is a liability,” she said. “There are a lot of reasons why other people do not come onto our property. The only people doing business with us are those harvesting our crops, planting our crops, or irrigating or doing other agricultural work.”
FGT officials first contacted Roberts in June with a request to do a survey, she said. She refused, she said, and they responded with “We are going to do it anyway.”

U.S. Sugar’s concerns go beyond boreholes.
Heavy machinery and vehicle traffic can cause soil compaction and soil and elevation loss in the Glades’ organic muck. A privately built and privately maintained water-management system on which sugarcane depends could be damaged. Surveying, soil sampling and other tests, and if there is ultimately a pipeline, could disrupt farming operations and production.
In addition, farmers are concerned about the crop-killing pasture mealy bug that could be spread by visiting gas company workers and contractors. Gov. Ron DeSantis recently signed an emergency order to add the invasive pest to the state’s list of severe agricultural emergencies.
What’s ahead
Before FGT can submit its application to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, it must complete its preliminary surveys and tests, meaning the results of these suits are critical. FGT will need to obtain a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity from FERC and file permits with several other regulatory agencies, such as the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission.
FGT is owned by a joint venture of Texas-based Energy Transfer and Kinder Morgan. Energy Transfer spokesperson Vicki Anderson Granado said the company does not comment on issues related to current or pending legal matters.
NextEra and FPL officials also declined to comment about the pipeline proposal.
FGT is suing Roberts’ family’s Sugar and Spice Inc., and Adams Holdings, along with other farms and agricultural entities, including Camaro Farms Inc., H&A Farm Leasing LLC, Janette Campbell, Enerwall Inc., Bunevall Inc., W.E. McKinstry Inc., and Jane B. Evans Farms Ltd.
U.S. Sugar and landowners who lease land to U.S. Sugar are also named in the complaints. They are Frances B. Ethridge, Burke Farms Inc., Burke Properties LLLP, SBG Farms Inc., Mary Burke, Johnson Farms LLC and James A. Ball IV.
Related filings
In September, U.S. Sugar filed a complaint in Hendry County against FGT that also names Chesapeake Utilities Corp. It asks a judge to prevent FGT workers from entering its properties.
Chesapeake and its subsidiary, Peninsula Pipeline Co., have announced the Florida Energy Pathway, a proposed $1.2 billion gas pipeline that will connect with FGT’s pipeline in South Bay and extend 97 miles to Miami.
“The property is not vacant ground. It is a working sugarcane farm, carrying standing cane eight to 12 feet high in dense planted rows,” U.S. Sugar’s filing states.
FGT’s plans also call for a 5,000-horsepower compression station to be built on U.S. Sugar’s land in Palm Beach County.
While FPL is not an owner in the FGT pipeline, it would be among the customers. However, through its parent company, it has an interest in the Florida Energy Pathway that would connect to the 38-mile segment.
In September, Next Energy Resources, a subsidiary of NextEra Energy, bought a 49% interest in the Florida Energy Pathway, the South Bay-to-Miami project. NextEra Energy is FPL’s parent company.
Roberts said she supports a strong domestic energy industry and understands that South Florida needs additional energy infrastructure, including pipelines and power lines, to support its growth. She serves on the Palm Beach County Business Development Board.
“But supporting infrastructure does not mean landowners should be expected to simply roll over when their property and livelihoods are at stake. That won’t happen here,” Roberts said.
“There are other less restrictive pathways, such as railroad and road rights of way,” Roberts said. “It would be less destructive to private property owners. At some point, somebody needs to explain why it is OK to do this.”

Who is Florida Gas Transmission Co.?
FGT is owned by Citrus Corp., a 50/50 joint venture between two Texas energy companies, Energy Transfer and Kinder Morgan.
FGT is one of three major gas pipeline companies operating in Florida. The other two are Gulfstream and Sabal Trail.
FGT operates nearly 5,300 miles of interstate natural gas transmission pipelines, from South Texas to South Florida. It is Florida’s original gas transmission pipeline operator. It began operations in Florida in 1959.
On Nov. 3, Energy Transfer reported net income of $1.21 billion for the quarter ended Sept. 30. It ranks sixth on Fortune’s Energy Sector Leader list by revenue and more and manages over 140,000 miles of underground pipeline across 44 states. The company says it supplies more than 60% of the natural gas used in Florida.
In October, Kinder Morgan reported record third-quarter results with $764 million in net income. It owns an interest in or operates about 78,000 miles of pipelines across North America and transports about 40% of the natural gas produced in the country.
Florida and natural gas
Natural gas fuels about 75% of Florida’s electricity generation, according to the Federal Energy Information Administration.
FPL produces 66.2% of its electricity from natural gas, 19.6% from nuclear, and 11% from solar, with purchased power, coal and oil making up the remainder.
Florida, the fourth-largest consumer of natural gas after Texas, Louisiana and California, produces no natural gas. Florida’s supply comes via pipelines from the Gulf states.
